- Time travel is possible based on the laws of physics, according to researchers.
- But time-travelers wouldn’t be able to alter the past in a measurable way, they say.
- And the future would essentially stay the same, according to the reseachers.
Imagine you could hop into a time machine, press a button, and journey back to 2019, before the novel coronavirus made the leap from animals to humans.
What if you could find and isolate patient zero? Theoretically, the COVID-19 pandemic wouldn’t happen, right?
Not quite, because then future-you wouldn’t have decided to time travel in the first place.
For decades, physicists have been studying and debating versions of this paradox: If we could travel back in time and change the past, what would happen to the future?
A 2020 study offered a potential answer: Nothing.
“Events readjust around anything that could cause a paradox, so the paradox does not happen,” Germain Tobar, the study’s author previously told IFLScience.
Tobar’s work, published in the peer-reviewed journal Classical and Quantum Gravity in September 2020, suggests that according to the rules of theoretical physics, anything you tried to change in the past would be corrected by subsequent events.
Put simply: It’s theoretically possible to go back in time, but you couldn’t change history.
The grandfather paradox
Physicists have considered time travel to be theoretically possible since Albert Einstein came up with his theory of relativity. Einstein’s calculations suggest it’s possible for an object in our universe to travel through space and time in a circular direction, eventually ending up at a point on its journey where it’s been before – a path called a closed time-like curve.
Still, physicists continue to struggle with scenarios like the coronavirus example above, in which time-travelers alter events that already happened. The most famous example is known as the grandfather paradox: Say a time-traveler goes back to the past and kills a younger version of his or her grandfather. The grandfather then wouldn’t have any children, erasing the time-traveler’s parents and, of course, the time-traveler, too. But then who would kill Grandpa?
A take on this paradox appears in the movie “Back to the Future,” when Marty McFly almost stops his parents from meeting in the past – potentially causing himself to disappear.
To address the paradox, Tobar and his supervisor, Dr. Fabio Costa, used the “billiard-ball model,” which imagines cause and effect as a series of colliding billiard balls, and a circular pool table as a closed time-like curve.
Imagine a bunch of billiard balls laid out across that circular table. If you push one ball from position X, it bangs around the table, hitting others in a particular pattern.
The researchers calculated that even if you mess with the ball’s pattern at some point in its journey, future interactions with other balls can correct its path, leading it to come back to the same position and speed that it would have had you not interfered.
“Regardless of the choice, the ball will fall into the same place,” Dr Yasunori Nomura, a theoretical physicist at UC Berkeley, previously told Insider.
Tobar’s model, in other words, says you could travel back in time, but you couldn’t change how events unfolded significantly enough to alter the future, Nomura said. Applied to the grandfather paradox, then, this would mean that something would always get in the way of your attempt to kill your grandfather. Or at least by the time he did die, your grandmother would already be pregnant with your mother.
Back to the coronavirus example. Let’s say you were to travel back to 2019 and intervene in patient zero’s life. According to Tobar’s line of thinking, the pandemic would still happen somehow.
“You might try and stop patient zero from becoming infected, but in doing so you would catch the virus and become patient zero, or someone else would,” Tobar said, according to Australia’s University of Queensland, where Tobar graduated from.
Nomura said that although the model is too simple to represent the full range of cause and effect in our universe, it’s a good starting point for future physicists.